Why pulling out of Syria is the only sane decision

I fully support President Trump’s decision to pull US troops out of Syria. I don’t agree with everything Trump does, but in this instance he is displaying exactly the kind of courage in public policy that our country needs right now. I think there are a lot of Americans who quietly agree with me. I do not think these views have been articulated, even by conservative media. So I am going to articulate them here.

First, I am going to cite my personal bias: I am from a military family.

My father was a combat veteran in Vietnam. He was drafted into the Army in 1968-69, the peak of the war over there. He fought as a door gunner on a helicopter gunship with the 101st Airborne. Men fighting in his position had a life expectancy of 30 seconds in battle. Our family considers it a bona fide miracle that he survived. Most of his peers did not.

Like most combat veterans, my father refused to tell many stories about his time in combat. My parents saved the letters they wrote each other during his time there. Well, they saved his letters to her; he was forced to burn her letters after he read them. It was common for the opposing side to steal family correspondence and write vicious things back to soldiers’ loved ones back home. And they could contain sensitive information about the war.

Occasionally, he would see a movie about Vietnam and then he’d go sit in his truck and sob for hours. He had violent nightmares through my entire childhood, and continues to have violent nightmares now that his is in his 70s.

Imagine your dysfunctional government forcing you to experience such horrific and traumatic events that you are having nightmares about them 50 years after the fact. I can tell you from personal experience that combat quite literally re-wires your brain. It permanently changes your neural chemistry and the pathways your mind is willing and able to entertain. The psychological impact of combat on veterans is on par with a profound physical handicap.

My father came home from war in the height of the cultural revolution in the US. He experienced many of the typical things veterans experienced then. He was chewed out by strangers when they saw him in uniform. He attempted to finish college, but his mind was not able to focus on the ordinary concerns of young adults post-combat. He came home one day and threw his medals in the garbage – including his Bronze Star for Valor in Combat, which he earned for fighting in battles like Hamburger Hill.

I come from a family of immigrants, but I am proud to say that every generation of my family has produced a soldier for this country. My grandfather stormed Normandy in World War II. My cousin was stationed in the DMZ in Korea, and knows what it is like to stand guard at a place where a firefight could break out any second. We are a family of warriors, and I love that.

My father has no judgment for Trump for dodging the draft in a war that he himself would have preferred never to have been sent to. He considers that a rational decision. My father had to kill a man on his 21st birthday – an event that most Americans celebrate by going out bar-hopping with friends and getting black-out drunk – who was sneaking into his camp in the middle of the night to slaughter his fellow soldiers. He understood the necessity of that action, but he still struggles with the image of that man’s eyes in the dark night. He had to end that life. The life of someone who probably felt equally justified in what he was about to do. Many people talk about such decisions, from the luxurious position of not having to make them in the world that exists beyond social media, as if they are black-and-white political issues. They absolutely are not.

My father’s situation was not all that different from the experiences of soldiers in the Middle East right now. They are off fighting in wars that most Americans have forgotten or never knew existed. If it weren’t a perceived opportunity to snub Trump, the media would not be covering any aspect of these conflicts right now. In the Common Core era of American education, I doubt most young Americans can point to Syria on a map. Or Yemen, for that matter. Or Somalia. Many were only born when the events that sent us into Afghanistan occurred. There were no actual events that sent us into Iraq. That was a scam. We send soldiers to risk their lives in wars that are, frankly, mostly irrelevant to most Americans. At the very least, they are not understood by most Americans. I am certain our Founding Fathers never anticipated such a situation. Heck, some of these wars have no formal authorization from Congress. That would break the Founding Fathers’ brains.

We have spent essentially $8 trillion on wars in the Middle East in my lifetime. And the same people who can’t find Syria on a map likewise are not experiencing the economic fact of having to pay for those wars. This is not like World War II when food is getting rationed and women can’t buy pantyhose. Where every family knows someone who died in combat and the sacrifices seem necessary and inevitable. The swamp creatures that keep us in these eternal wars are borrowing that money from China and Japan, with interest, and they just re-finance that debt over and over and over again. The cost of servicing the country’s debt alone is starting to become a budget component that should not be ignored. But we just start financing more of the country’s day-to-day operations instead of changing. That’s a problem for future generations. It’s immoral.

Think of the opportunity cost of that spending for a second. Imagine some parallel universe where Americans spent $8 trillion on public schools, infrastructure, or the space program. We would be a very different country right now. The most popular people on the debate stage would not be apologists for Stalin’s ideology. A lot of things have shattered this country and its political discourse, but it’s not hard to see the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan as the proximate cause for our own cold civil war.

The thing that pisses me off the most about the wars in the Middle East, however, is this: If we were going to intervene militarily in any region right now, it should be Central America and providing military assistance to Mexico to break apart its drug cartels. The unrest in these countries – which are not on the other side of the world from us, but merely to the south – is creating real humanitarian and economic crises for the US. Right here, on our soil. Yet we keep sending our grandchildren’s treasure to the Middle East. A trillion here, a trillion there. If you challenge that status quo, you must be an irrational, uneducated deplorable.

In the last federal fiscal year, nearly one million people – mostly humanitarian and economic refugees, but accompanied by a not insignificant number of bad actors as well – attempted to cross the southern border. Most of them have nothing and pose nothing but a social cost on the US population. They are experiencing incomprehensible suffering, and the US – wealthy as this nation is – is not in a financial position to support all of them.

Most of the heroin and other drugs on the streets in the US have come across the southern border, and cartels know how to use the humanitarian crisis they have helped create to conceal their evil shadow economy. Every major city in the US now has a homelessness crisis that is really simply a drug crisis. Even the tiny beach town that we live in now has several heroin camps hidden out in the middle of the jungle.

If you bring up these concerns about immigration policy, you are usually deemed a racist or xenophobe, no matter how many good intentions you have. Here in Florida, we live among the refugees from socialism and drug cartels. I can tell you from talking to these people directly that they are not Bernie bros. The naivete of our politics stuns them.

How did we get to the point where we will spend trillions of dollars fighting in wars the US was never logically a counterparty to, while addicts rot in plain view and our southern border is plagued with the destruction of brutal, evil tyrants that are only an hour plane ride away from the US?

There are no heroes in the civil war in Syria, no matter how many crocodile tears the establishment sheds for the Kurds. Our participation in that conflict is not as simple as the media and policymakers who are on defense contractors’ payrolls make it seem. During the Obama administration, the Pentagon and the CIA were arming folks on both sides of the conflict. Americans were seriously paying for US interests to fight each other. As long as more guns get sold, Washington doesn’t complain. For the same reason they don’t care that cancer drugs cost $50,000.

If you want to argue that the US should stay in several conflicts in the Middle East indefinitely, that’s fine. But I want to hear you acknowledge that in saying that, you are also saying that you want kids in the US to get a garbage education. That you want people in the US to sit on bridges with poor safety ratings during their morning commute. That endless wars are more important than health care reform or stabilizing Social Security and Medicare. That sending our youth to make sure the Kurds and Turkish forces play nice is the single biggest political priority to you. Because when you quantify the cost of these wars, that is where it ranks in reality.

3 thoughts on “Why pulling out of Syria is the only sane decision

  1. I’m have multiple (somewhat contradictory?) thoughts on this topic.

    1 – declare victory and go home. Securing a supply of fossil fuels for our economy is no longer needed as amongst North America we have plenty, and are a next exporter (or very shortly will be so) So why are we there again? Why are we spending so much blood and treasure in the middle east? Because we have already? A good example of the sunk cost fallacy?

    2 – (I’m a bit thin on this, so correct if wrong) The kurds were helpful with our wars in the area and while they might not be the nicest, they are the least worst? if we are going to leave the area (and I think we should) shouldn’t we do so in a manner that does not leave such a massive quick vacuum to allow others to rush in that we may not want there? A managed, obfuscated retreat, giving us time to set up the board after we leave if what I’m driving at.

    3 – (even thinner) Aren’t a lot of the problem of the middle east due to the lines drawn one weekend by a British diplomat near the end of WW1 (1918?) You have ethnic groups straddling borders. My knowledge is really thin in this area but isn’t some of the tension in the area due to this?

    Liked by 1 person

  2. The concept of Syria as a modern state came from boundaries drawn up by diplomats in the WWI era, and that’s about all the connection there is there. There have been quite a few revolts and power grabs by various groups since then. They took the US’s side in the first Iraq war. The second Iraq war produced over a million refugees that destabilized the area and turned the region into a breeding ground for terrorists. Obama maybe could have helped contain this particular crisis in the region back then by taking control of initial conditions, but that didn’t happen. At around the same time, the region suffered from an enormous drought, which drove millions of people from rural areas into cities, where they started fighting for resources and where groups who could tolerate each other while they were spread apart were suddenly up in each other’s faces.

    Borders in the Middle East are almost nonsensical in general. These tribal interests have been fighting each other for hundreds of years, with the sporting aristocrats from western societies using other people’s children to put their thumb on one group or another for isolated decades at a time. We arm one group, help them win, then they start slaughtering another group because what else would they do with their newfound power? We then arm that group, help them win, then they start slaughtering another group. Eventually we are getting shot at by our own weapons by people we helped train. And we help mint a zillion terrorists in the process, who are recruiting people with narratives of war that no average American could ever explain.

    Consider the experience of the Syrian equivalent of a Millennial right now. For all of their formative years – for some of them, their entire life – they have watched American soldiers policing the region. Literally the only reason the US is marching around in their backyard is that the US is so rich (on bond proceeds) that we can afford as a country to have recreational wars. Even when the US is putting their thumb on your side of the scale, the fighting between the US and others is destroying the city you live in. Cities American Millennials can’t even name. Do you think they think we are saviors with perfect intentions?

    I just watched a video of Kurds throwing fruit at US servicemen as they were driving out of the area. This notion that these troops are brothers at war with Kurds is pretty insane. All sides of the Syrian conflict use chemical weapons. Turkish forces love white phosphorous, Assad drops napalm on elementary schools. Every participant, including the Kurds, have their own terrorist groups that would make the narcos in Mexico blush.

    Our participation in these conflicts, which seems so urgent to some people now, is just a blip in the story arc of war over there. We are the rich uncle that distant relatives want to call on for help settling debts, but that no one actually loves. Meanwhile it is sabotaging the economic future of our country and polluting our culture with co-opted symbols of hate and slavery. We have crackpots in the US arguing that wearing a burka is a feminist act instead of an act of violence. The inner cities of western states are full of refugees, who get to live in squalor while their “saviors” step over them and put men with machine guns at tourist destinations.

    It’s almost remarkable how much global economic value a region the size of Florida can nuke.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s